From Fedora Project Wiki

(Notes on RHL names)
Line 89: Line 89:
| Neper || Goddard is a Moon crater in Mare Marginis <ref> http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mare_Marginis </ref> so is his nearest brother - Neper. ||  Neper project not updated for about year <ref> http://sourceforge.net/projects/neper/ </ref> || {{check}} || || space, stars, galaxies, lunar modules, possibly black and white theme also view of earth from moon is amazing || ||  
| Neper || Goddard is a Moon crater in Mare Marginis <ref> http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mare_Marginis </ref> so is his nearest brother - Neper. ||  Neper project not updated for about year <ref> http://sourceforge.net/projects/neper/ </ref> || {{check}} || || space, stars, galaxies, lunar modules, possibly black and white theme also view of earth from moon is amazing || ||  
|-
|-
| Elizabeth || Robert H. Goddard is a famous person who lived in Worcester, Massachusetts, so is Elizabeth Bishop, a highly-regarded 20th century poet. || No collisions, only localized results pertaining to Elizabeth, New Jersey. || {{check}} || || Elizabeth Bishop was poet laurete of the United States from 1949 - 1950; a noir theme reflecting the style of the era would work well (watch the film "LA Confidential"; also think about the color scheme of 1950s retro-noir ads you've seen).  || ||
| Elizabeth || Robert H. Goddard is a famous person who lived in Worcester, Massachusetts, so is Elizabeth Bishop, a highly-regarded 20th century poet. || No collisions, only localized results pertaining to Elizabeth, New Jersey. || {{caution}} || Very common name, not unusual enough. || Elizabeth Bishop was poet laurete of the United States from 1949 - 1950; a noir theme reflecting the style of the era would work well (watch the film "LA Confidential"; also think about the color scheme of 1950s retro-noir ads you've seen).  || ||
|-
|-
| Tudek || Goddard is an archaeological site <ref>[http://www.mnh.si.edu/vikings/voyage/subset/vinland/archeo.html Goddard Archaeological Site]</ref> in North America where a 2nd century Norwegian coin was found.  Tudek is also an archaeological site in North America.<ref>[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tudek_Site Tudek Archaeological Site]</ref>  || No collisions found || {{check}} || || Themed with artifacts, exploration, maps, compasses (Indiana Jones type stuff) || ||
| Tudek || Goddard is an archaeological site <ref>[http://www.mnh.si.edu/vikings/voyage/subset/vinland/archeo.html Goddard Archaeological Site]</ref> in North America where a 2nd century Norwegian coin was found.  Tudek is also an archaeological site in North America.<ref>[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tudek_Site Tudek Archaeological Site]</ref>  || No collisions found || {{check}} || || Themed with artifacts, exploration, maps, compasses (Indiana Jones type stuff) || ||
Line 109: Line 109:
| Turing || Peter Goddard is a British scientist educated at Cambridge University, as was Alan Turing || There is a trademark held by Holt Software Associates for their language "Turing", I don't know if that would preclude its use here.  It would seem that Alan Turing himself is more commonly associated with the term than their product. [[http://www.turingsoft.com/profile.htm Turing Pvt Ltd] also generates a hit. --[[User:Pfrields|pfrields]]]''|| {{caution}} || || I think some cool things could be done with the concept of a Turing engine or cryptography. || ||
| Turing || Peter Goddard is a British scientist educated at Cambridge University, as was Alan Turing || There is a trademark held by Holt Software Associates for their language "Turing", I don't know if that would preclude its use here.  It would seem that Alan Turing himself is more commonly associated with the term than their product. [[http://www.turingsoft.com/profile.htm Turing Pvt Ltd] also generates a hit. --[[User:Pfrields|pfrields]]]''|| {{caution}} || || I think some cool things could be done with the concept of a Turing engine or cryptography. || ||
|-
|-
| Gama || Goddard (,John) was a famous explorer and goal achiever, as was [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vasco_Gama Vasco da Gama] (15th century Portuguese Navigator known worldwide as he spearheaded the World Discoveries). || No coalitions with IT world || || || Freedom (adventure, exploration), First (First in many things as Vasco da Gama), Friends (explore together) > convert to freedom, exploration, first, leading. Not much problems with internationalization of "Gama" where it's very close in phonetics to "gamma". || ||
| Gama || Goddard (,John) was a famous explorer and goal achiever, as was [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vasco_Gama Vasco da Gama] (15th century Portuguese Navigator known worldwide as he spearheaded the World Discoveries). || No coalitions with IT world ''[[http://www.gnu.org/software/gama/ GNU Gama] and [https://neesforge.nees.org/projects/gama/ NEES grid certificate management software] show up, not sure about TMs. --[[User:Pfrields|pfrields]]]'' || {{caution}} || || Freedom (adventure, exploration), First (First in many things as Vasco da Gama), Friends (explore together) > convert to freedom, exploration, first, leading. Not much problems with internationalization of "Gama" where it's very close in phonetics to "gamma". || ||
|-
|-
| Robert || Goddard is an American college established in 1863 (in Vermont), and so is Robert (in Turkey). || No obvious IT trademark on Robert; Robert Ludlum (an author, deceased) apparently a trademark of Myn Pyn, LLC.  Robert Young was CEO of Red Hat.  || || || Educational or learning theme || ||
| Robert || Goddard is an American college established in 1863 (in Vermont), and so is Robert (in Turkey). || No obvious IT trademark on Robert; Robert Ludlum (an author, deceased) apparently a trademark of Myn Pyn, LLC.  Robert Young was CEO of Red Hat.  || {{caution}} || Very common name, not unusual enough. || Educational or learning theme || ||
|-
|-
| Emancipation || Goddard (College) is an American institution established in 1863, and so is the Emancipation Proclamation (something of a stretch, but a cool name, imo -- note that 1863 was the year the announcement made in 1862 went into effect). || "Software Emancipation Technology" was a software company in Massachusetts that appears to now be called "Progress Software" (and "Upspring" prior to that).  || || || Freedom/Liberation theme || ||
| Emancipation || Goddard (College) is an American institution established in 1863, and so is the Emancipation Proclamation (something of a stretch, but a cool name, imo -- note that 1863 was the year the announcement made in 1862 went into effect). || "Software Emancipation Technology" was a software company in Massachusetts that appears to now be called "Progress Software" (and "Upspring" prior to that).  || || || Freedom/Liberation theme || ||

Revision as of 21:15, 24 April 2010

Important.png
READ THE GUIDELINES!
Name suggestions are now being accepted. Please read the guidelines before contributing to maximize chances that your suggestion can be on the ballot.

Rules

This page contains community suggestions for the Fedora 13 release name. All submissions must meet the guidelines for release names.

Constantine → Goddard → <new name>? Goddard is a <blank>, and so is <new name>.

The link between Constantine and Goddard was "both are names of rocket scientists." The link between Goddard and the new name must be different than that link, and different from any other previous link.

Note.png
General links automatically rejected
General links such as "is a word" or "is a location", while technically within the scope of the rules, will most certainly be rejected by the Fedora Board. Remember, the goal is to come up with a creative link to Goddard. The following links will also likely be rejected:
  • Other kinds of scientists
  • ...
Please try to find a truly original and obscure link!

Naming Schedule

PROPOSED:

  • Name collection: April 21 to April 27
  • List to Fedora Board: April 27 to April 29
  • Legal Review of Board approved names: April 29 to May 3
  • Community vote on final name: May 4 to 10
  • Name announced: May 11

Name Suggestions

Important.png
Please read carefully.
The instructions below will help prevent some suggestions from being eliminated early.

How to use this table

  1. Come up with a name idea. Put the name in the first column.
  2. Determine whether it passes the "is-a" test. You must be able to truthfully complete the sentence "Goddard is a <...>, and so is <YOUR_NAME>." The link to the new name cannot be the same as the link from Constantine to Goddard, nor any other previous link. Mark the link in the appropriate column, such as "type of chemical reaction," "deep-sea organism."
    • Don't choose obvious links, because they usually result in uninteresting names.
    • Don't choose very general names or unclear links.
    • Do choose obscure links to interesting things, which makes for a better name.
    • Do avoid all previous links wherever possible.
    • Do make sure there are at least a couple of ways to link out of the new name to the next name -- and they must be unique too!
  3. Use Google to search for possible trademark collisions. First search for the term itself along with "+software", and then broaden your search to include "+computer", "+hardware", "+technology", "+IT", and so on. Do not skimp on this step.
    • If you find a collision, it is best to find another name. Names that cause collisions will be eliminated by Red Hat's Legal department and thus waste their time, which is a valuable commodity for Fedora. Help us maximize their effectiveness by weeding out names that are trademarks of other entities, especially those in the IT industry.
    • If the collision is outside the IT/computing market, you can still submit the name but you should note the collision in the "Tested" column, and include a link to the site where the collision was found.
    • If you find no collisions, make that notation in the "Tested" column.
  4. Do not mark the approval columns. These are reserved for the approval authorities such as the Board and Red Hat Legal.


Suggestion Table

Name "Is a..." Tested Initial Approval Comments Themeable Board Approved Legal Approved
Guinness Sir Alec Guinness was a legendary british actor like Willoughby Goddard. He plays in great movies like Lawrence of Arabia, Doctor Zhivago, Hotel Paradiso and so on. No easy collisions in IT, computers, technology. Red Hat 7 was codenamed 'Guinness'. Warning.png Reusing old Red Hat Linux names is not preferred. Themeable according to his great movies like "Lawrance of Arabia" (an arabic like dessert theme)
Scofield Paul Scofield was a legendary british actor like Willoughby Goddard. He plays great roles in Shakespeare dramas. "Scofield Associates," local Maryland (USA) vendor, probably low risk since they don't even have a web site Checkmark.png Themeable according to his great roles in Shakespeare plays like MacBeth Henry V
Bhanji or Kingsley "Sir Ben Kingsley born as Krishna Bhanji is a legendary british actor like Willoughby Goddard. He plays historical persons like Mahatma Gandhi, Simon Wiesenthal and Wladimir Iljitsch Lenin Checkmark.png Checkmark.png Themeable according to his great historical roles
Astro Goddard is a fictional dog character in a cartoon series and so is Astro. Many collisions with computer stores. Warning.png
Bacon Like Willoughby Goddard, Kevin Bacon is a legendary actor (although not British). (Furthermore Bacon as well as Goddard are both names of asteroids discovered by van Houten, C. J., van Houten-Groeneveld, I. and Gehrels, T.) There's a Bacon Software and there's Jono Bacon, but we seem ok in terms of operating systems/Linux-related collisions. Checkmark.png Infinite possibilities. Bacon strips, cute little piggies in the background, a Canadian Bacon wallpaper for our users in that country. And other scientific stuff too, I suppose. Bonus: using "is a person to whom other people claim connection" as the connection - see Six Degrees of Kevin Bacon and the Erdos number - we could name F15 "Erdos," which gives us the option of linking out to tons of cool math stuff.
Marshall Goddard is a space flight center and so is Marshall. Numerous collisions in technology and computers. Warning.png (a) Historical Western Films (b) Rebuilding (Marshall Plan)
Korolyov Goddard is a space flight center and so is Korolyov. Checkmark.png Checkmark.png Scientist, city...
Neutron Goddard is the name of Jimmy Neutron's dog in a cartoon series. Jimmy Neutron was also a scientist in the series. Numerous computer stores. Warning.png Lots of color scheme options with atoms, neutrons, protons, etc.
Baudelaire Stuart Leslie Goddard[1] is a famous artist with bipolar disorder. So was Charles Baudelaire.[2] I couldn't find anything related to software/IT/technology trademarks. Checkmark.png Baudelaire was an french writer/poet, so his work could probably inspire our artists. Only the name of his most famous work "Les fleurs du Mal" (meaning "The flowers of Evil") could provide some ideas...
Tsiolkovsky Robert H. Goddard was an early rocketry pioneer and so was Konstantin Tsiolkovsky. No easy collisions in software, IT, computers, technology Checkmark.png Plenty of theme opportunities in rockets and spaceflight
Vortex Goddard is the name of a main character in Jimmy Neutron cartoon series, so is Cindy Vortex. Numerous collisions in IT and computers. Warning.png [Negative connotations. --pfrields] Lots of vortices themes options.
Shepherd Robert H. Goddard was an American rocketry pioneer, Alan Shepherd was the first American in space. [1] Warning.png Exploring more opportunities in space related themes.
Button Goddard is a typo in the name of a famous film director. So is Button. [3] No obvious collisions Checkmark.png
Katyusha Goddard was a pioneer of controlled, liquid-fueled rocketry , and "Katyusha multiple rocket launchers" is a type of rocket artillery first built and fielded by the Soviet Union in World War II. Katyusha Records software, but this looks to be a dead project. Checkmark.png Themable according to its use in wars till today, so fedora will have: Power, Speed, Weapon...
Aberdeen Goddard is a place in Maryland, as is Aberdeen. Aberdeen Group offers services in IT/consulting industry. Warning.png Aberdeen Proving Ground, MD is a leader in United States Army research and development, so Army related themes would be appropriate.
Mitikas Goddard is a peak [4] so is Mitikas. Checkmark.png Checkmark.png
Rubbia Peter Goddard is a mathematical physicist and Carlo Rubbia [5] is a physicist who won a Nobel Prize in Physics for work leading to the discovery of the W and Z particles at CERN. No collisions Checkmark.png It can be themeable according to physics, atoms, and maybe CERN
Neper Goddard is a Moon crater in Mare Marginis [6] so is his nearest brother - Neper. Neper project not updated for about year [7] Checkmark.png space, stars, galaxies, lunar modules, possibly black and white theme also view of earth from moon is amazing
Elizabeth Robert H. Goddard is a famous person who lived in Worcester, Massachusetts, so is Elizabeth Bishop, a highly-regarded 20th century poet. No collisions, only localized results pertaining to Elizabeth, New Jersey. Warning.png Very common name, not unusual enough. Elizabeth Bishop was poet laurete of the United States from 1949 - 1950; a noir theme reflecting the style of the era would work well (watch the film "LA Confidential"; also think about the color scheme of 1950s retro-noir ads you've seen).
Tudek Goddard is an archaeological site [8] in North America where a 2nd century Norwegian coin was found. Tudek is also an archaeological site in North America.[9] No collisions found Checkmark.png Themed with artifacts, exploration, maps, compasses (Indiana Jones type stuff)
Fytnargin Goddard is a mountain with elevation 4134m and so is Fytnargin in Russia None found Checkmark.png
Adam Stuart Leslie Goddard uses the stage name Adam Ant. Many collisions in software field Warning.png theme around biblical Genesis story
Lakeland Goddard is a fast growing city in Kansas and so is Lakeland in Florida [10] Lakeland Micro Warning.png Swans are kind of a mascot for the city. Also, the Florida aspect could be included with Sunny skies or beaches.
Worcester Robert Hutchings Goddard (October 5, 1882 – August 10, 1945), U.S. professor of physics and scientist, was a pioneer of controlled, liquid-fueled rocketry. Goddard was born in 1882 in Worcester, Massachusetts, Due to its location in Central Massachusetts, Worcester is often referred to as the "Heart of the Commonwealth". A few local store collisions, nothing in OS field Checkmark.png
Chaplin Paulette Goddard[11] was a silent film's actress also was Charles Chaplin genetic haplotype software, very old Checkmark.png Actors, Silent films, 1920'
Laughlin Robert Goddard was a professor of physics, and so is Robert Laughlin.[12]. He was awarded the 1998 Nobel Prize in physics for his explanation of the fractional quantum Hall effect. Moreover he argues for emergence which is a concept that says "The whole is more than the sum of its parts". Fedora is more than a sum of softwares. Laughlin is a town in Nevada (USA). John Mc Laughlin is a musician. Clarence John Laughlin was a photographer. Laughlin is also a memorial hosptial in Tennessee. [Nothing specific in software. --pfrields] Checkmark.png Something that can illustrate the emergence concept, like multiple objects combined to create a new one (more complex).
Beardmore The Goddard coin in an ancient Norse artifact and so are the Beardmore Relics [13]. No software related trademarks found Checkmark.png Vikings, sea, ships, medieval weapons, exploration, artifacts
Turing Peter Goddard is a British scientist educated at Cambridge University, as was Alan Turing There is a trademark held by Holt Software Associates for their language "Turing", I don't know if that would preclude its use here. It would seem that Alan Turing himself is more commonly associated with the term than their product. [Turing Pvt Ltd also generates a hit. --pfrields] Warning.png I think some cool things could be done with the concept of a Turing engine or cryptography.
Gama Goddard (,John) was a famous explorer and goal achiever, as was Vasco da Gama (15th century Portuguese Navigator known worldwide as he spearheaded the World Discoveries). No coalitions with IT world [GNU Gama and NEES grid certificate management software show up, not sure about TMs. --pfrields] Warning.png Freedom (adventure, exploration), First (First in many things as Vasco da Gama), Friends (explore together) > convert to freedom, exploration, first, leading. Not much problems with internationalization of "Gama" where it's very close in phonetics to "gamma".
Robert Goddard is an American college established in 1863 (in Vermont), and so is Robert (in Turkey). No obvious IT trademark on Robert; Robert Ludlum (an author, deceased) apparently a trademark of Myn Pyn, LLC. Robert Young was CEO of Red Hat. Warning.png Very common name, not unusual enough. Educational or learning theme
Emancipation Goddard (College) is an American institution established in 1863, and so is the Emancipation Proclamation (something of a stretch, but a cool name, imo -- note that 1863 was the year the announcement made in 1862 went into effect). "Software Emancipation Technology" was a software company in Massachusetts that appears to now be called "Progress Software" (and "Upspring" prior to that). Freedom/Liberation theme
Apollo Goddard Space Flight Center is a NASA installation. The Apollo Program was NASA's project to land the first human on the moon. Apollo M. O. Smith was an American rocket scientist as was Robert H. Goddard. Since Apollo was both an Ancient Greek as well as a Roman god, there are plenty of collisions everywhere (including hard- and software products and companies) but exactly because of the fact that the term has been used for literally thousands of years and is very famous it's so generic that I don't think that should be much of a trademark problem. Apollo was the codename for Red Hat Linux 5.2 Warning.png Reusing old Red Hat Linux names is not preferred. Ancient Greek and Roman gods, mythology. The fact that he was god of music, healing, prophecy and enlightenment seems to fit Fedora as a project well. There seems to be an Apollo in almost everything [14] which provides nearly endless possibilities.
(Pallas) Goddard[15] and Pallas are both asteroids of the so-called “main belt”. The latter is also the largest asteroid and the the second asteroid to have been discovered. See the comment above. Otherwise there are thousands of other names of asteroids that could be used instead of “Pallas” (but they would probably be less nice ^^). Update: Could be a trademark issue, see [16] Warning.png asteroids, astronomy/cosmos in general, Greco-Roman mythology etc.[17]
Europa (For the case that there is a trademark problem with “Pallas”:) Europa is also (among others) the name of an asteroid.[18] Too generic to be a trademark problem IMHO. thousand of possibilities (see also above)
Lausanna Goddard[15] and Lausanna are both asteroids of the so-called “main belt”. Lausanna is the old spelling of Lausanne, a town in Switzerland, so Fedora 15 could be named after another Swiss town/village. Not found asteroids, astronomy/cosmos in general etc.
Alfvén Goddard[15] and Alfvén are both asteroids of the so-called “main belt” that are both discovered by Cornelis Johannes van Houten, Ingrid van Houten-Groeneveld and Tom Gehrels. Alfvén is also the name of a great Swedish composer so there are many possible names for Fedora 15. Not found asteroids, astronomy/cosmos in general etc.

Various connections that could be explored. "Goddard is a ..."

  • a lunar crater
  • a drinking vessel
  • a major space science laboratory
  • a French film director from the mid-20th century (note: it's Jean-Luc Godard, with one d)
  • ...

Approval Mark Legend

Approval Mark Meaning
Checkmark.png Approved
Stop (medium size).png Rejected
Warning.png Under review

Rejected Suggestions

Name "Is a..." Tested Initial Approval Comment Themeable Board Approved Legal Approved