AxelThimm/kmdls/voting

http://www.redhat.com/archives/fedora-packaging/2006-August/msg00061.html Hi,

I suggest to vote through email about replacing the current kernel scheme with the kmdl or similar scheme.

a) kernel module scheme needs uname-r-in-name

b) kernel module scheme needs one-specfile approach (for both usreland and kernel modules)

c) kernel module scheme needs to be kernel agnostic (both version
 * and* flavour)

d) support for coinstallation of kmdls should be pushed into FC6 asap (working plugin has already been submitted here and tested be ATrpms users). Requires a positive vote on a-c)

e) Adoption of kmdl interface scheme as used at ATrpms and outlined on http://fedoraproject.org/wiki/AxelThimm/kmdls. Requires a positive vote on a-d)

f) Assignment to kmdl-task force to integrate kmdl support into the buildsystems used by Fedora (myself volunteering). Requires a positive vote on a-e)

g) Allow kmdl package submissions to Fedora Core/Extras. Requires a positive vote on a-f)

Without voting, but dependent on vote results: Assist in GFS kmdl packaging (altready done at FC4 times, needs to resurface). -- Axel.Thimm at ATrpms.net

Note: voting was concluded on Wed, Aug 23rd 2006, 16:00 UTC. Any missing votes were notes as "0" - only +1 votes count for passing a proposal, and 6 out of 10 are needed. Therefore none of the proposals passed.

{| border="1"
 * ||a ||b ||c ||d ||e ||f ||g
 * TomCallaway   ||-1||-1||-1||-1||-1||-1||-1
 * RexDieter     ||+1||+1||+1||+1||+1||+1||+1
 * JesseKeating  ||-1||-1||-1||-1||-1||-1||-1
 * ToshioKuratomi || 0||-1||-1||-1||-1||-1||-1
 * DavidLutterkort|| 0|| 0|| 0|| 0|| 0|| 0|| 0
 * VilleSkyttä   || 0||-1||-1||-1||-1||-1||-1
 * AxelThimm     ||+1||+1||+1||+1||+1||+1||+1
 * JasonTibbitts || 0|| 0|| 0|| 0|| 0|| 0|| 0
 * RalfCorsepius || 0|| 0|| 0|| 0|| 0|| 0|| 0
 * JoseOliveira  || 0|| 0|| 0|| 0|| 0|| 0|| 0
 * Sum           ||+2 -26 votes missing||+2 -44 votes missing||+2 -44 votes missing||+2 -44 votes missing||+2 -44 votes missing||+2 -44 votes missing||+2 -44 votes missing
 * passes        ||no||no||no||no||no||no||no
 * VilleSkyttä   || 0||-1||-1||-1||-1||-1||-1
 * AxelThimm     ||+1||+1||+1||+1||+1||+1||+1
 * JasonTibbitts || 0|| 0|| 0|| 0|| 0|| 0|| 0
 * RalfCorsepius || 0|| 0|| 0|| 0|| 0|| 0|| 0
 * JoseOliveira  || 0|| 0|| 0|| 0|| 0|| 0|| 0
 * Sum           ||+2 -26 votes missing||+2 -44 votes missing||+2 -44 votes missing||+2 -44 votes missing||+2 -44 votes missing||+2 -44 votes missing||+2 -44 votes missing
 * passes        ||no||no||no||no||no||no||no
 * JoseOliveira  || 0|| 0|| 0|| 0|| 0|| 0|| 0
 * Sum           ||+2 -26 votes missing||+2 -44 votes missing||+2 -4<BR>4 votes missing||+2 -4<BR>4 votes missing||+2 -4<BR>4 votes missing||+2 -4<BR>4 votes missing||+2 -4<BR>4 votes missing
 * passes        ||no||no||no||no||no||no||no
 * Sum           ||+2 -2<BR>6 votes missing||+2 -4<BR>4 votes missing||+2 -4<BR>4 votes missing||+2 -4<BR>4 votes missing||+2 -4<BR>4 votes missing||+2 -4<BR>4 votes missing||+2 -4<BR>4 votes missing
 * passes        ||no||no||no||no||no||no||no
 * passes        ||no||no||no||no||no||no||no