Changes/BtrfsByDefault

Make btrfs the Workstation and KDE default file system

Summary

LVM+ext4 has served us well, and it will remain available and supported for custom installs. The default file system for Workstation and KDE installs shall be btrfs.

Owner

• Name: Your Name
• Email: <your email address so we can contact you, invite you to meetings, etc. Please provide your Bugzilla email address if it is different from your email in FAS>

• Product: Workstation edition, and KDE spin
• Responsible WG: Workstation working group, and KDE SIG

Current status

• Targeted release: Fedora 33
• Last updated: 2020-06-19
• FESCo issue: <will be assigned by the Wrangler>
• Tracker bug: <will be assigned by the Wrangler>
• Release notes tracker: <will be assigned by the Wrangler>

Detailed Description

The change is based on the installer's custom partitioning btrfs preset. It's been well tested for 7 years.

Current partitioning
vg/root LV mounted at / and a vg/home LV mounted at /home. These are separate file system volumes, with separate free/used space.

Proposed partitioning
root subvolume mounted at / and home subvolume mounted at /home. Subvolumes don't have size, they act mostly like directories, space is shared.

Unchanged
/boot will be a small ext4 volume. A separate boot is needed to boot dm-crypt sysroot installations; it's less complicated to keep the layout the same, regardless of whether sysroot is encrypted. There will be no automatic snapshots/rollbacks.

Optimizations (Optional)

The detailed description above is the proposal. It's intended to be a minimalist and transparent switch. It's also the same as was proposed (and accepted) for Fedora 16. The following optimizations improve on the proposal, but are not critical. They are also transparent to most users. The general idea is agree to the base proposal first, and then consider these as enhancements.

Boot on btrfs

• Instead of a 1G ext4 boot, create a 1G btrfs boot.
• Advantage: Makes it possible to include in a snapshot and rollback regime. GRUB has stable support for btrfs for 10+ years.
• Scope: Contingent on bootloader and installer team review and approval.

Compression

• Enable transparent compression using zstd on select directories: /usr /var/lib/flatpak ~/.local/share/flatpak
• Advantage: Saves space and significantly reduces write amplification. May improve performance in some instances.
• Scope: Contingent on installer team review and approval to enhance anaconda to set the proper XATTR for each directory.

Additional subvolumes

• /var/log/ /var/lib/libvirt/ and ~/.local/share/gnome-boxes/images/ will use separate subvolumes.
• Advantage: Makes it easier to excluded them from snapshots, rollbacks, and send/receive.
• Scope: Anaconda knows how to do this already, just change the kickstart to add additional subvolumes, contingent on Anaconda review and approval.

Feedback

Red Hat doesn't support btrfs? Can Fedora do this?

Red Hat supports Fedora well, in many things. But Fedora already works closely with, and depends on, upstreams. And this will be one of them. That's an important consideration for this proposal. The community has a stake in ensuring it is supported. Red Hat will never support btrfs if Fedora rejects it. Fedora necessarily needs to be first, and make the persuasive case that it solve more problems than alternatives. Feature owners believe it does, hands down.

What about UI/UX and integration in the desktop?

If btrfs isn't the default file system, there's no commitment, nor reason to work on any UI/UX integration. There are ideas to make certain features discoverable. None are planned for Fedora 33. Anaconda already has sophisticated btrfs integration.

What btrfs features are recommended and supported?

This is the upstream btrfs feature status page

Fedora is a community project. What is supported within Fedora depends on what the community decides to put forward in terms of resources.

When in doubt, use defaults. Be patient with yourself, and each other. There are few things you must learn about btrfs, but the toy box is full. It can be overwhelming. Features that sound familiar, like raid1, don't work the same as other implementations you're familiar with. There is lots of jargon. Take your time. No one needs to go from 0 kph to 100 kph overnight.

What is possible but not supported?

No btrfs features will be disabled. The full box of toys is available. It is possible to get into trouble. You might also have more fun.

Benefit to Fedora

btrfs solves the following problems.

• Users running out of free space on either / or /home Workstation issue #152
  • "one big file system": no hard barriers like partitions or logical volumes
  • transparent compression: significantly reduces write amplification, improves lifespan of storage hardware
  • reflinks and snapshots are more efficient for use cases like containers (Podman supports both)
• Poor desktop responsiveness when under pressure Workstation issue #98
  • Currently only btrfs has proper IO isolation capability via cgroupsv2
  • Completes the resource control picture: memory, cpu, IO isolation
• Storage devices betray users, resulting in data corruption
  • Everything is checksummed and verified on every read
  • Corrupt data results in EIO, instead of resulting in application confusion, and isn't replicated into backups and archives
• File system resize
  • Online shrink and grow are fundamental to the design

Scope

• Proposal owners:
  • Submit PR's for Anaconda to change default_scheme = BTRFS to the proper product files: Workstation, KDE.
  • Multiple test days: build community support network
  • Aid with documentation

• Other developers:
  • Anaconda, review PRs and merge
  • Bootloader team, review PRs and merge

• Release engineering: #Releng issue number

• Policies and guidelines: N/A

• Trademark approval: N/A

Upgrade/compatibility impact

Change will not affect upgrades.

Documentation will be provided for existing btrfs users to "retrofit" their setups to that of a default btrfs installations (base plus any approved options).

How To Test

Today
Do a custom partitioning installation; change the scheme drop-down menu to btrfs; click the blue "automatically create partitions"; and install.
Fedora 31, 32, Rawhide, on x86_64 and ARM.

Once change lands
It should be simple enough to test, just do a normal install.

User Experience

Pros

• Mostly transparent
• Space savings from compression
• Longer lifespan of hardware, also from compression.
• Utilities for used and free space, CLI and GUI, are expected to behave the same. No special commands are required.
• More detailed information can be revealed by btrfs specific commands.

Enhancements opportunities

updatedb does not index /home when /home is a bind mount Also can affected rpm-ostree installations, including Silverblue.

GNOME Usage: Incorrect numbers when using multiple btrfs subvolumes This isn't btrfs specific, happens with "one big ext4" volume as well.

GNOME Boxes, RFE: create qcow2 with 'nocow' option when on btrfs /home This is btrfs specific, and is a recommended optimization for both GNOME Boxes and virt-manager.

containers/libpod: automatically use btrfs driver if on btrfs

Dependencies

None.

Contingency Plan

• Contingency mechanism: Owner will revert changes back to LVM+ext4
• Contingency deadline: Beta freeze

• Blocks release? Yes
• Blocks product? Workstation and KDE

Documentation

Strictly speaking no documentation is required reading. But documentation will exist to help guide users below the minimal changes on the surface.

For those who want to know more:

btrfs wiki main page

man 5 btrfs contains: mount options, features, swapfile support, checksum algorithms, and more
man btrfs contains an overview of the btrfs subcommands
man btrfs <subcommand> will show the man page for that subcommand

NOTE: The btrfs command will accept partially subcommand as long as it's not ambiguous. These are equivalent commands:
btrfs subvolume snapshot
btrfs sub snap
btrfs su sn

You'll discover your own convention. It might be preferable to write out the full command on forums and lists, but then maybe some folks don't learn about this shortcut?

There will be some minimal Fedora documentation to help get the ball rolling.

Release Notes

The default file system is btrfs.