From Fedora Project Wiki

No edit summary
Line 36: Line 36:
'''Larry Cafiero - FAmSCo'''<br/>
'''Larry Cafiero - FAmSCo'''<br/>
A no-brainer: Yes, I run Fedora on a majority of my computers. I have a computer lab in Felton, California, called Redwood Digital Research and most of the work computers there run on Fedora. The desktop which runs the business (accounting, correspondence, etc.) is still running Fedora 10 because it works so well for the basic things it does that I never upgraded it. My laptops have been running Fedora 14 since alpha.
A no-brainer: Yes, I run Fedora on a majority of my computers. I have a computer lab in Felton, California, called Redwood Digital Research and most of the work computers there run on Fedora. The desktop which runs the business (accounting, correspondence, etc.) is still running Fedora 10 because it works so well for the basic things it does that I never upgraded it. My laptops have been running Fedora 14 since alpha.
'''Marcus Moeller - FAmSCo'''<br/>
Yes, I run the latest version of Fedora (managed with Spacewalk) on my office PC and mixed Versions of Fedora at home.


=== Do you think Fedora should focus on the Desktop? Or someplace else? If so, where? ===
=== Do you think Fedora should focus on the Desktop? Or someplace else? If so, where? ===
Line 44: Line 47:
'''Larry Cafiero - FAmSCo'''<br/>
'''Larry Cafiero - FAmSCo'''<br/>
This is not a FAmSCo issue, specifically, however it does affect Ambassadors indirectly. The word "focus" is probably the wrong word here -- should we continue our work on the desktop/laptop environment or explore other environments? I believe that we should continue our work on the desktop but also continue to develop and explore other environments as well. I think we do a fairly good job here.
This is not a FAmSCo issue, specifically, however it does affect Ambassadors indirectly. The word "focus" is probably the wrong word here -- should we continue our work on the desktop/laptop environment or explore other environments? I believe that we should continue our work on the desktop but also continue to develop and explore other environments as well. I think we do a fairly good job here.
'''Marcus Moeller - FAmSCo'''<br/>
Fedora is a good choice for a lot of tasks, e.g. desktops but even servers. If you are in need of running the latest version of http, php or mysql why not stick with Fedora?


=== What do you think of the Community Working Group that was just established? ===
=== What do you think of the Community Working Group that was just established? ===
Line 49: Line 55:
'''Sandro Mathys - BOARD'''<br/>
'''Sandro Mathys - BOARD'''<br/>
I like the CWGs purpose very much and I offered to serve in it myself. Nevertheless, I'm not exactly sure whether the tasks for the CWG are not actually tasks of the board, the steering committees and the mentors. But the people who decided to create the CWG thought about that already for sure. Maybe a clearer delimitation should be made but I think what the CWG really does and is responsible for will only become clear once it's been actively working for a while.
I like the CWGs purpose very much and I offered to serve in it myself. Nevertheless, I'm not exactly sure whether the tasks for the CWG are not actually tasks of the board, the steering committees and the mentors. But the people who decided to create the CWG thought about that already for sure. Maybe a clearer delimitation should be made but I think what the CWG really does and is responsible for will only become clear once it's been actively working for a while.




Line 56: Line 61:
'''Sandro Mathys - BOARD'''<br/>
'''Sandro Mathys - BOARD'''<br/>
Getting Fedora back into a state where things (can) get done and where bleeding edge is lived.
Getting Fedora back into a state where things (can) get done and where bleeding edge is lived.





Revision as of 15:11, 8 November 2010

Important.png
Candidates should add their responses directly on this wiki page.
Please note that not all questions need to be answered, e.g. a FAmSCo candidate should not need to answer very technical questions.

Main questions

What is your take on bundled libraries?

Sandro Mathys - BOARD
In my opinion the current policy is the correct approach and should be adhered to.

What ideas do you have related to the implementation of the stable updates vision?

Sandro Mathys - BOARD
While I understand the need for stability, I think Fedora is well-known and popular for being bleeding-edge. Many developers and users feel that Fedora is becoming too stable recently and not the place to develop new things anymore. The stable updates vision recommends such users to use rawhide instead but I think that's very often a tad too broken for most people so we'd need something in between, similar to the branches of future releases but implemented as a rolling release like rawhide.

Larry Cafiero - FAmSCo
This is not a FAmSCo issue, and it's unclear which of these questions should be answered by FAmSCo candidates. But for the record, I think there can be a balance between what we normally do in being cutting edge and maintaining stability. As an observation, it appears with the last couple of releases we have been shedding the "myth" that Fedora is too hard for new users, which is a huge plus, and I think that scores one point for the stability side.

Is there any new initiative you would like to see happen during your term to improve packaging?

Larry Cafiero - FAmSCo
This is not a FAmSCo issue, and it's unclear which of these questions should be answered by FAmSCo candidates. Unless we are talking about the sleeves that the media comes in, packaging is not a FAmSCo issue.

Do you think it's important to have more people vote in Fedora elections? If so, how would you encourage that?

Sandro Mathys - BOARD
Yes, definitely. I would try to increase the awareness of just how important it is to vote in elections but I think in the end the real problem is that people just don't vote even if they now why they should. Probably only some kind of directly connected reward would help to chance that but unfortunately I can't come up with a good idea on how that could look like.

Larry Cafiero - FAmSCo
Finally, a FAmSCo issue, or at least one related to FAmSCo. Clearly it is important to have more people vote in Fedora elections, and those who care about the direction of the Fedora Project do. Unfortunately, many don't, and the reason why is a mystery. How do you have more people vote in Fedora elections? The answer could range from draconian -- vote or be dropped from the project -- to pleading -- please vote . . . please? -- to offering prizes for voting (which of course borders on bribery). While I don't advocate any of the aforementioned, I firmly believe it's an issue of personal responsibility: if you care enough about the Fedora Project, you'll vote and have a say in the direction of the project. If you don't vote, don't complain. It's pretty much that simple.

Do you run Fedora on the computer you use most often? If so what Desktop? If not, why not?

Sandro Mathys - BOARD
Yes, I do - actually Fedora 14 with the lovely KDE desktop is running on all of them: my office workstation, my home workstation (there's also a win7 for fancy gaming purposes on that one, though), my laptop and my netbook.

Larry Cafiero - FAmSCo
A no-brainer: Yes, I run Fedora on a majority of my computers. I have a computer lab in Felton, California, called Redwood Digital Research and most of the work computers there run on Fedora. The desktop which runs the business (accounting, correspondence, etc.) is still running Fedora 10 because it works so well for the basic things it does that I never upgraded it. My laptops have been running Fedora 14 since alpha.

Marcus Moeller - FAmSCo
Yes, I run the latest version of Fedora (managed with Spacewalk) on my office PC and mixed Versions of Fedora at home.

Do you think Fedora should focus on the Desktop? Or someplace else? If so, where?

Sandro Mathys - BOARD
Focusing sounds much like we should stop doing what we're good in - to allow everyone to work on everything. I sure think Fedora should focus more on the desktop than on servers, but as long as there's someone thinking Fedora should become the #1 server distribution why stop them working on that goal? Better have some features that only a few people ask for than missing features a lot of people would need.

Larry Cafiero - FAmSCo
This is not a FAmSCo issue, specifically, however it does affect Ambassadors indirectly. The word "focus" is probably the wrong word here -- should we continue our work on the desktop/laptop environment or explore other environments? I believe that we should continue our work on the desktop but also continue to develop and explore other environments as well. I think we do a fairly good job here.

Marcus Moeller - FAmSCo
Fedora is a good choice for a lot of tasks, e.g. desktops but even servers. If you are in need of running the latest version of http, php or mysql why not stick with Fedora?

What do you think of the Community Working Group that was just established?

Sandro Mathys - BOARD
I like the CWGs purpose very much and I offered to serve in it myself. Nevertheless, I'm not exactly sure whether the tasks for the CWG are not actually tasks of the board, the steering committees and the mentors. But the people who decided to create the CWG thought about that already for sure. Maybe a clearer delimitation should be made but I think what the CWG really does and is responsible for will only become clear once it's been actively working for a while.


What if anything would you do about the number of more seasoned contibutors that are reducing involvement in the project?

Sandro Mathys - BOARD
Getting Fedora back into a state where things (can) get done and where bleeding edge is lived.


In one sentence, can you summarize what the Board does and in another what FESco does and in a third what FAmSCo does ?

Sandro Mathys - BOARD
The board works on the vision of Fedora and the strategy to get there (and eventually to implement the non-technical points in the strategy). FESCo works on how to implement the strategy, mostly from a technical point of view. FAmSCo works on the strategy, and supports the implementation of it, regarding the ambassadors' main task which is to promote Fedora locally.

FAmSCo Questions

FAmSCo_questionnaire