Talk:OpenID

From FedoraProject

(Difference between revisions)
Jump to: navigation, search
(sending of optional info has a bug)
m (SugarLabs)
 
(12 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
= tested sites =
+
== FAS upgrades that have OpenID changes ==
== [http://freshmeat.net/ freshmeat.net] ==
+
 
=== result ===
+
2009-05-06 -- Minor fixes to quoting in openid provider
 +
 
 +
== tested sites ==
 +
=== [http://freshmeat.net/ freshmeat.net] ===
 +
==== result ====
 
fail
 
fail
=== tested ===
+
==== tested ====
 
on 2009-04-05 by pcfe.
 
on 2009-04-05 by pcfe.
=== comment ===
+
2009-05-07 by abadger1999
 +
2010-10-17 by wzzrd
 +
 
 +
==== comment ====
 
goes back to the freshmeat.net login page after approving at FAS.
 
goes back to the freshmeat.net login page after approving at FAS.
 
No surprise, it is known broken.
 
No surprise, it is known broken.
  
== [http://wikitravel.org/ wikitravel.org] ==
+
=== [http://wikitravel.org/ wikitravel.org] ===
=== result ===
+
==== result ====
 
fail
 
fail
=== tested ===
+
==== tested ====
 
on 2009-04-05 by pcfe.
 
on 2009-04-05 by pcfe.
=== comment ===
+
2009-05-07 by abadger1999
 +
2010-10-17 by wzzrd
 +
 
 +
==== comment ====
 
After a long load time it reports 'Verification of the OpenID URL was cancelled'.
 
After a long load time it reports 'Verification of the OpenID URL was cancelled'.
  
== [http://news.ycombinator.org HackerNews] ==
+
=== [http://news.ycombinator.org HackerNews] ===
=== result ===
+
==== result ====
 
fail
 
fail
=== tested ===
+
==== tested ====
 
on 2009-04-5 by mapleoin
 
on 2009-04-5 by mapleoin
 +
2009-05-07 by abadger1999
 +
2010-10-17 by wzzrd
  
=== comment ===
+
==== comment ====
  
 
FAS gets asked for the credentials, but upon returning to news.ycombinator.org it says:
 
FAS gets asked for the credentials, but upon returning to news.ycombinator.org it says:
Line 29: Line 41:
 
   Bad OpenID login.
 
   Bad OpenID login.
  
== [http://stackoverflow.com StackOverflow] ==
+
=== [http://stackoverflow.com StackOverflow] ===
=== result ===
+
==== result ====
fail (used to work a few months ago)
+
works again as of (at least) 2010-10-17
=== tested ===
+
 
 +
==== tested ====
 
on 2009-04-05 and ''a few months ago'' by mapleoin
 
on 2009-04-05 and ''a few months ago'' by mapleoin
+
2009-05-07 by abadger1999
=== comment ===
+
2010-10-17 by wzzrd
StackOverflow doesn't send the user to FAS, it just says:
+
 
  Unable to log in with your OpenID provider:
+
==== comment ====
  OpenID parameter 'session_type' was missing from the query.
+
Stackoverflow creates empty userXXXXXXX account and does not use values provided by FAS, like the username.
  
== [http://www.thinkwiki.org ThinkWiki] ==
+
=== [http://www.thinkwiki.org ThinkWiki] ===
=== result ===
+
==== result ====
 
works
 
works
=== tested ===
+
works but has bug
 +
==== tested ====
 
on 2009-04-07 by pcfe
 
on 2009-04-07 by pcfe
=== comment ===
+
2009-05-07 by abadger1999
 +
==== comment ====
 
I chose to only transmit some of the values that ThinkWiki wanted (namely only my timezone), as (in my eyes) they do not need the other requested information. Works just fine.
 
I chose to only transmit some of the values that ThinkWiki wanted (namely only my timezone), as (in my eyes) they do not need the other requested information. Works just fine.
  
Line 54: Line 69:
 
--[[User:Toshio|abadger1999]] 15:23, 7 May 2009 (UTC)
 
--[[User:Toshio|abadger1999]] 15:23, 7 May 2009 (UTC)
  
== [http://wiki.sugarlabs.org SugarLabs] ==
+
=== [http://wiki.sugarlabs.org SugarLabs] ===
=== result ===
+
==== result ====
Does not work
+
Works
  
=== tested ===
+
==== tested ====
 
[[User:Bochecha|Mathieu Bridon]] 12:27, 25 April 2009 (UTC)
 
[[User:Bochecha|Mathieu Bridon]] 12:27, 25 April 2009 (UTC)
 +
2009-05-07 by abadger1999
 +
2010-10-18 by wzzrd
 +
 +
==== comment ====
 +
Though the page is riddled with php errors when authenticating with OpenID through FAS, it does work.
 +
 +
=== [https://sourceforge.net/account/login.php SourceForge] ===
 +
==== result ====
 +
Works fine as of (at least) 2010-10-17
 +
 +
==== tested ====
 +
<s>[[User:Bochecha|Mathieu Bridon]] 22:53, 15 September 2009 (UTC)</s>
 +
 +
[[User:Bochecha|Mathieu Bridon]] 09:36, 9 October 2009 (UTC)
 +
 +
Found working by wzzrd on 2010-10-17
 +
 +
==== comment ====
 +
Best so far: asks FAS for account information and actually does something with it.
 +
 +
=== [http://gitorious.com gitorious.com] ===
 +
==== result ====
 +
works
 +
 +
==== tested ====
 +
on 2010-10-7 by wzzrd
 +
 +
==== comment ====
 +
 +
=== [http://identi.ca identi.ca] ===
 +
==== result ====
 +
works
 +
 +
==== tested ====
 +
on 2010-10-17 by wzzrd
 +
 +
==== comment ====
 +
 +
=== [http://slashdot.org slashdot.org] ===
 +
==== result ====
 +
works
 +
 +
==== tested ====
 +
on 2010-10-17 by wzzrd
 +
 +
==== comment ====
 +
 +
=== [http://bitbucket.org bitbucket.org] ===
 +
==== result ====
 +
works
 +
 +
==== tested ====
 +
on 2010-10-17 by wzzrd
 +
 +
==== comment ====
  
=== comment ===
 
I get the following message:
 
'''Verification error'''
 
An error occured during verification of the OpenID URL.
 
  
== [http://example.com example] ==
+
=== [http://example.com example] ===
=== result ===
+
==== result ====
  
=== tested ===
+
==== tested ====
 
on  by
 
on  by
  
=== comment ===
+
==== comment ====

Latest revision as of 07:19, 18 October 2010

Contents

[edit] FAS upgrades that have OpenID changes

2009-05-06 -- Minor fixes to quoting in openid provider

[edit] tested sites

[edit] freshmeat.net

[edit] result

fail

[edit] tested

on 2009-04-05 by pcfe. 2009-05-07 by abadger1999 2010-10-17 by wzzrd

[edit] comment

goes back to the freshmeat.net login page after approving at FAS. No surprise, it is known broken.

[edit] wikitravel.org

[edit] result

fail

[edit] tested

on 2009-04-05 by pcfe. 2009-05-07 by abadger1999 2010-10-17 by wzzrd

[edit] comment

After a long load time it reports 'Verification of the OpenID URL was cancelled'.

[edit] HackerNews

[edit] result

fail

[edit] tested

on 2009-04-5 by mapleoin 2009-05-07 by abadger1999 2010-10-17 by wzzrd

[edit] comment

FAS gets asked for the credentials, but upon returning to news.ycombinator.org it says:

 Bad OpenID login.

[edit] StackOverflow

[edit] result

works again as of (at least) 2010-10-17

[edit] tested

on 2009-04-05 and a few months ago by mapleoin 2009-05-07 by abadger1999 2010-10-17 by wzzrd

[edit] comment

Stackoverflow creates empty userXXXXXXX account and does not use values provided by FAS, like the username.

[edit] ThinkWiki

[edit] result

works works but has bug

[edit] tested

on 2009-04-07 by pcfe 2009-05-07 by abadger1999

[edit] comment

I chose to only transmit some of the values that ThinkWiki wanted (namely only my timezone), as (in my eyes) they do not need the other requested information. Works just fine.

I chose to allow some extra information like nickname but got this:

> Your OpenID server did not provide a nickname (either because it cannot, or because you told it not to).

--abadger1999 15:23, 7 May 2009 (UTC)

[edit] SugarLabs

[edit] result

Works

[edit] tested

Mathieu Bridon 12:27, 25 April 2009 (UTC) 2009-05-07 by abadger1999 2010-10-18 by wzzrd

[edit] comment

Though the page is riddled with php errors when authenticating with OpenID through FAS, it does work.

[edit] SourceForge

[edit] result

Works fine as of (at least) 2010-10-17

[edit] tested

Mathieu Bridon 22:53, 15 September 2009 (UTC)

Mathieu Bridon 09:36, 9 October 2009 (UTC)

Found working by wzzrd on 2010-10-17

[edit] comment

Best so far: asks FAS for account information and actually does something with it.

[edit] gitorious.com

[edit] result

works

[edit] tested

on 2010-10-7 by wzzrd

[edit] comment

[edit] identi.ca

[edit] result

works

[edit] tested

on 2010-10-17 by wzzrd

[edit] comment

[edit] slashdot.org

[edit] result

works

[edit] tested

on 2010-10-17 by wzzrd

[edit] comment

[edit] bitbucket.org

[edit] result

works

[edit] tested

on 2010-10-17 by wzzrd

[edit] comment

[edit] example

[edit] result

[edit] tested

on by

[edit] comment