Talk:OpenID

From FedoraProject

(Difference between revisions)
Jump to: navigation, search
(page creation)
 
m (SugarLabs)
 
(17 intermediate revisions by 5 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
= tested sites =
+
== FAS upgrades that have OpenID changes ==
== freshmeat.net ==
+
 
=== result ===
+
2009-05-06 -- Minor fixes to quoting in openid provider
 +
 
 +
== tested sites ==
 +
=== [http://freshmeat.net/ freshmeat.net] ===
 +
==== result ====
 
fail
 
fail
=== tested ===
+
==== tested ====
 
on 2009-04-05 by pcfe.
 
on 2009-04-05 by pcfe.
=== comment ===
+
2009-05-07 by abadger1999
goes back to the freshmeat.net ogin page after approving at FAS.
+
2010-10-17 by wzzrd
 +
 
 +
==== comment ====
 +
goes back to the freshmeat.net login page after approving at FAS.
 
No surprise, it is known broken.
 
No surprise, it is known broken.
 +
 +
=== [http://wikitravel.org/ wikitravel.org] ===
 +
==== result ====
 +
fail
 +
==== tested ====
 +
on 2009-04-05 by pcfe.
 +
2009-05-07 by abadger1999
 +
2010-10-17 by wzzrd
 +
 +
==== comment ====
 +
After a long load time it reports 'Verification of the OpenID URL was cancelled'.
 +
 +
=== [http://news.ycombinator.org HackerNews] ===
 +
==== result ====
 +
fail
 +
==== tested ====
 +
on 2009-04-5 by mapleoin
 +
2009-05-07 by abadger1999
 +
2010-10-17 by wzzrd
 +
 +
==== comment ====
 +
 +
FAS gets asked for the credentials, but upon returning to news.ycombinator.org it says:
 +
 +
  Bad OpenID login.
 +
 +
=== [http://stackoverflow.com StackOverflow] ===
 +
==== result ====
 +
works again as of (at least) 2010-10-17
 +
 +
==== tested ====
 +
on 2009-04-05 and ''a few months ago'' by mapleoin
 +
2009-05-07 by abadger1999
 +
2010-10-17 by wzzrd
 +
 +
==== comment ====
 +
Stackoverflow creates empty userXXXXXXX account and does not use values provided by FAS, like the username.
 +
 +
=== [http://www.thinkwiki.org ThinkWiki] ===
 +
==== result ====
 +
works
 +
works but has bug
 +
==== tested ====
 +
on 2009-04-07 by pcfe
 +
2009-05-07 by abadger1999
 +
==== comment ====
 +
I chose to only transmit some of the values that ThinkWiki wanted (namely only my timezone), as (in my eyes) they do not need the other requested information. Works just fine.
 +
 +
I chose to allow some extra information like nickname but got this:
 +
 +
> Your OpenID server did not provide a nickname (either because it cannot, or because you told it not to).
 +
 +
--[[User:Toshio|abadger1999]] 15:23, 7 May 2009 (UTC)
 +
 +
=== [http://wiki.sugarlabs.org SugarLabs] ===
 +
==== result ====
 +
Works
 +
 +
==== tested ====
 +
[[User:Bochecha|Mathieu Bridon]] 12:27, 25 April 2009 (UTC)
 +
2009-05-07 by abadger1999
 +
2010-10-18 by wzzrd
 +
 +
==== comment ====
 +
Though the page is riddled with php errors when authenticating with OpenID through FAS, it does work.
 +
 +
=== [https://sourceforge.net/account/login.php SourceForge] ===
 +
==== result ====
 +
Works fine as of (at least) 2010-10-17
 +
 +
==== tested ====
 +
<s>[[User:Bochecha|Mathieu Bridon]] 22:53, 15 September 2009 (UTC)</s>
 +
 +
[[User:Bochecha|Mathieu Bridon]] 09:36, 9 October 2009 (UTC)
 +
 +
Found working by wzzrd on 2010-10-17
 +
 +
==== comment ====
 +
Best so far: asks FAS for account information and actually does something with it.
 +
 +
=== [http://gitorious.com gitorious.com] ===
 +
==== result ====
 +
works
 +
 +
==== tested ====
 +
on 2010-10-7 by wzzrd
 +
 +
==== comment ====
 +
 +
=== [http://identi.ca identi.ca] ===
 +
==== result ====
 +
works
 +
 +
==== tested ====
 +
on 2010-10-17 by wzzrd
 +
 +
==== comment ====
 +
 +
=== [http://slashdot.org slashdot.org] ===
 +
==== result ====
 +
works
 +
 +
==== tested ====
 +
on 2010-10-17 by wzzrd
 +
 +
==== comment ====
 +
 +
=== [http://bitbucket.org bitbucket.org] ===
 +
==== result ====
 +
works
 +
 +
==== tested ====
 +
on 2010-10-17 by wzzrd
 +
 +
==== comment ====
 +
 +
 +
=== [http://example.com example] ===
 +
==== result ====
 +
 +
==== tested ====
 +
on  by
 +
 +
==== comment ====

Latest revision as of 07:19, 18 October 2010

Contents

[edit] FAS upgrades that have OpenID changes

2009-05-06 -- Minor fixes to quoting in openid provider

[edit] tested sites

[edit] freshmeat.net

[edit] result

fail

[edit] tested

on 2009-04-05 by pcfe. 2009-05-07 by abadger1999 2010-10-17 by wzzrd

[edit] comment

goes back to the freshmeat.net login page after approving at FAS. No surprise, it is known broken.

[edit] wikitravel.org

[edit] result

fail

[edit] tested

on 2009-04-05 by pcfe. 2009-05-07 by abadger1999 2010-10-17 by wzzrd

[edit] comment

After a long load time it reports 'Verification of the OpenID URL was cancelled'.

[edit] HackerNews

[edit] result

fail

[edit] tested

on 2009-04-5 by mapleoin 2009-05-07 by abadger1999 2010-10-17 by wzzrd

[edit] comment

FAS gets asked for the credentials, but upon returning to news.ycombinator.org it says:

 Bad OpenID login.

[edit] StackOverflow

[edit] result

works again as of (at least) 2010-10-17

[edit] tested

on 2009-04-05 and a few months ago by mapleoin 2009-05-07 by abadger1999 2010-10-17 by wzzrd

[edit] comment

Stackoverflow creates empty userXXXXXXX account and does not use values provided by FAS, like the username.

[edit] ThinkWiki

[edit] result

works works but has bug

[edit] tested

on 2009-04-07 by pcfe 2009-05-07 by abadger1999

[edit] comment

I chose to only transmit some of the values that ThinkWiki wanted (namely only my timezone), as (in my eyes) they do not need the other requested information. Works just fine.

I chose to allow some extra information like nickname but got this:

> Your OpenID server did not provide a nickname (either because it cannot, or because you told it not to).

--abadger1999 15:23, 7 May 2009 (UTC)

[edit] SugarLabs

[edit] result

Works

[edit] tested

Mathieu Bridon 12:27, 25 April 2009 (UTC) 2009-05-07 by abadger1999 2010-10-18 by wzzrd

[edit] comment

Though the page is riddled with php errors when authenticating with OpenID through FAS, it does work.

[edit] SourceForge

[edit] result

Works fine as of (at least) 2010-10-17

[edit] tested

Mathieu Bridon 22:53, 15 September 2009 (UTC)

Mathieu Bridon 09:36, 9 October 2009 (UTC)

Found working by wzzrd on 2010-10-17

[edit] comment

Best so far: asks FAS for account information and actually does something with it.

[edit] gitorious.com

[edit] result

works

[edit] tested

on 2010-10-7 by wzzrd

[edit] comment

[edit] identi.ca

[edit] result

works

[edit] tested

on 2010-10-17 by wzzrd

[edit] comment

[edit] slashdot.org

[edit] result

works

[edit] tested

on 2010-10-17 by wzzrd

[edit] comment

[edit] bitbucket.org

[edit] result

works

[edit] tested

on 2010-10-17 by wzzrd

[edit] comment

[edit] example

[edit] result

[edit] tested

on by

[edit] comment