From Fedora Project Wiki
2009-08-11 From 12:00 to 21:00 UTC (8am -> 5pm EDT) #fedora-fit-and-finish)

What to test?[edit]

Today's instalment of Fedora Test Day will focus on user experience issues of peripherals. We are interesting in the problems you face when plugging anything into your computer, be it a mouse, a keyboard an external hard drive, a modem, a printer, a camera, a phone, a music player, a GPS or whatever.

Who's available[edit]

The following cast of characters will be available for testing, workarounds, bug fixes, and general discussion: Matthias Clasen, David Zeuthen, Bastien Nocera

Prerequisites for Test Day[edit]

  • An up-to-date rawhide installation. See the instructions on the Rawhide page on the various ways in which you can install or update to Rawhide. If that feels too risky to you, we also have recent rawhide live images available that allow you to participate without risking your existing installation. Tips on using a live image are available at FedoraLiveCD.

Note that the images will be removed shortly after the test day, since they are strictly for test day usage only. Warning: I was bit by the bug having to do with notification area icons not showing up. I killed nm-applet and ran it directly to get onto my wireless network.

Architecture SHA1SUM
i586 e9ab9f9846bea2d0d0eb4514a4048d9365a07950
x86_64 6f49f3f7b6a3fab49514c73035bdfe42a8ca1416
  • For the Go online with a phone test, you'll need the latest versions of NetworkManager and gnome-bluetooth
  • A variety of gizmos that can be plugged into a computer. See above for a representative list of devices that might be good to test
  • A good mood. Remember; while we are poking into things that may make us angry or frustrated, we are doing it to make things better

How to test[edit]

In this test day, we want to find small and large issues that ruin the user experience of working with devices that can be (hot-)plugged into your computer.

Test cases:

Here are some things to look at:

  • Does the desktop react in the right way if you plug in your device ?
  • Is a suitable icon used to represent the device ?
  • Do the relevant applications 'see' the device, e.g. does a music player appear in rhythmbox ?
  • Do applications react appropriately to the device being unplugged ?
  • Do things work in the same way if the device is already plugged in before boot or before login ?

Issues that were identified[edit]

Tester Description Bug references Status
pfps Messages when inserting and unmounting/ejecting filesystems #516739
hadess Sony Ericsson K850i wired connection appears in NM, but can't connect not yet
hadess CUPS Bluetooth backend crashes when discovering a new printer fixed in F11, rawhide
jlaska Plugging in 2 USB keyboards, each with different keymaps, doesn't work as expected. Keypresses on the second keyboard diplays a character that doesn't correspond to the key pressed.
hadess crash when closing the wizard after setting PAN fixed in rawhide
hadess/robert__ pulseaudio warnings #469416
mclasen unplugging a webcam causes trouble #516776
kparal copying data to usb stick is very fast and then hangs on 100% for a very long time gnome#591546
hadess Discovery for BT printers doesn't work fixed in F11, rawhide
hadess System-config-printer bug #516787 partially fixed
mclasen usb speakers show up as input, too #516783 wontfix
kparal USB webcam does not work #516986
kparal Bluetooth preferences have editable box Friendly name with non-editable text, which is confusing #516801 FIXED
kparal Error message in bluetooth transfers is hardly readable #516807
kparal Resizing windows in metacity using alt+middle mouse button is cancelled with wheel scroll gnome#591544
mclasen Too many dialogs when plugging a camera in gnome#591454
mclasen Camera icon does not go away gnome#591457
vbenes using bluetooth mouse is not smooth enough (one stuck each 5s) #516756
dpravec there was no volume control applet in the panel TBD
danw Disconnecting USB interface to UPS twice crashes gnome-session fdo#23256
dpravec blutetooth icon disappeared from panel (and phone from desktop) for unknown reason, not coming back even when i checked '[x] show bluetooth icon' in bluetooth preferences TBD
pfps cameras cause gnome-keyring problems #516808
verdurin Connecting K850 phone in 'phone mode' causes a kernel crash .. vbenes: see the same with SE P1i TBD
verdurin USB printer not configured automatically #517007 in progress
verdurin Photos on phone memory card not detected properly #517006

Things that work alright[edit]

Tester Description
pfps USB sticks work as usual (surprise!), except I see "Aug 11 09:11:29 localhost gnome-keyring-daemon[2253]: mount_added: assertion `identifier' failed" and "Aug 11 09:12:05 localhost gnome-keyring-daemon[2253]: no volume registered at: /media/CF" on unmount plus "Aug 11 09:13:40 localhost usb_id[3250]: unable to access '/devices/pci0000:00/0000:00:1d.7/usb1/1-2/1-2:1.0/host12/target12:0:0/12:0:0:0/block/sdc'" on eject
pfps USB to SATA disk works (and eject option available!), except I see the second and third messages from USB stick test above
pfps USB multi card reader works, except I see the first and second messages from USB stick test above
mclasen USB webcam works for both video and audio out of the box
kparal USB stick works ok - auto mounting, auto showing contents, showing desktop icon, showing warning for too large files, informing user when is safe to eject device

(see: - multiple partition bug on F11, also on rawhide?)

pfps PCMCAI to CF adaptor working as expected - modulo above messages
kparal Accessing data on phone using Bluetooth works ok
pfps Thinkpad T60p disk in bay (PATA->SATA!) works ok - modulo above messages
mclasen Changing sound output devices moves streams without glitch
mclasen Volume up/down keys on USB speakers bring up the OSD
pfps eject on USB sticks (and CF cards in adapters) correctly unmounts all partitions
pfps Filesystems with pictures correctly offer to import the pictures (Cameras are a different matter, though)
danw USB ethernet adapter shows up in nm-applet when plugged in, and NM falls back to next device when you unplug it
vbenes sending file to phone via bluetooth works fine