Archive:Zikula CMS Option

From FedoraProject

Jump to: navigation, search


Contents

Summary

the Zikula project has been around in one form or another since 2001, previously as PostNuke. Since the PostNuke days we've completely rewritten the core from the ground up, trying to keep a nice balance between practicality, performance and good architecture design. There's a strong API, we've had templating for years so output is easily modified by anyone who knows a bit of HTML and CSS, and our biggest thing is enterprise level security.

Many of the things we initially had as a differentiating factor, i.e APIs (most PHP CMSs didn't even have this when PostNuke started out), templating and so on are now in every CMS on the market. One thing we have maintained is the security focus, and I think we have that still over competitors.

Now, the obvious competitors that come to mind like Joomla and Drupal will have more modules, we can't claim to have such a large backing (though the community is big), but I can honestly say that I have never wanted for a module to build one of my sites - and I must have built hundreds. We are lucky in that a few super-powerful modules are flexible enough to cover 90% of situations.

For Fedora, I think the highlights are the security, our caching system (based on smarty), the fine grained permissions system, custom authentication and of course we are modular. The long, 8 year history tells you we're not going to disappear on you, Zikula will be around for a long time yet.

Project Website

http://www.zikula.org

Please excuse the slightly disorganised content, we recently refreshed our site and we're still in the process of updating the content and navigation to our liking.

Hardware Requirements

Apache/IIS (recommend Apache to get the best friendly URLs), PHP 5+ (though our 1.x series will work on PHP 4 I can't in good conscience recommend using it) and MySQL 4 or 5 (preferably 5). Gettext for the upcoming 1.2 version as an extension to PHP.

Features

Must have

Checkmark.png == Meets the requirement.

Warning.png == Partially meets the requirement.

Stop (medium size).png == Does not meet the requirement.

Requirement Status
Good security record Checkmark.png
Proactive, security minded developer community Checkmark.png
Highly responsive, especially to security issues Checkmark.png
Flexible enough auth system to attach to FAS via the json interface Warning.png
RSS Checkmark.png
L10n that doesn't break the translator workflow Checkmark.png
Output for Transifex (PO/POT)
Content workflow (write <=> edit => publish) Checkmark.png
Internal version control with rollback capability Checkmark.png
Content expiration (automatic) Checkmark.png
Multiple roles, e.g. writer, team lead, editor, publisher, managing editor Checkmark.png
Categorize/tag content for easy base organization Checkmark.png
Search that works Warning.png
Be a CMS as a core function, not an add-on Checkmark.png
Handle making certain pages or content areas static/non-database driven Warning.png
Must not lock us in. Data should be portable to another CMS. Checkmark.png
Packaged for Fedora Stop (medium size).png

Like to have

Checkmark.png == Meets the requirement.

Warning.png == Partially meets the requirement.

Stop (medium size).png == Does not meet the requirement.

Requirement Status
OpenID Checkmark.png
Good WYSIWYG editor Checkmark.png
Easy to organize content by taxonomy, structured and ad hoc
Support for draft->review->$foo->publish workflows Checkmark.png
Workflow to ship the content for l10n only at certain stages
Workflow go back to a certain stage if a mistake/error is found in the source-language content by the translator
Translators have a 'review' step in the workflow for translated content before it is published, so that they can see translations in context
Modern technology with a vibrant community and likelihood of being popular beyond the next twelve months Checkmark.png
Good federation tools to make it easy to find disparate content through one UI
One set of things it is great at, not be all things for all people
Be a modular design (v. monolithic) Checkmark.png
Have an active and large community Checkmark.png
Have support for DocBook

Explanations

Authentication

We have what we call Auth Modules, which allow us to authenticate against external sources. This can either take the details entered on the site, and send them elsewhere for checking, or alternatively I have previously redirected people to an external page to authenticate and the result of that is passed back to Zikula. I've personally implemented a system to authenticate against 'Raven' which is the authentication system used at the University of Cambridge here in the UK, and we have an OpenID module too

Translation

This is the one I wanted to talk about. With 1.2 (in development), our core at least is translated through gettext. That would be any strings inside the core, e.g status messages and the like. Content is a bit different. We have on our roadmap a plan to provide a generic way of translating content, however it's not there yet. So, translations are dependent on the module you use at the moment. I realise that might not be ideal, but presumably you would be using one main module for most content, so we could code up a better translations interface for one or two modules if it turns out to be a problem.

Search

Two systems, the old system is database-based and IMO does not work that well. We have a new system from the GSOC to replace it based on Zend Search Lucene which is a proper indexer and very nice. Needs some further development but is in a basically working state.

Dynamic/Static Pages

Not completely, no. The caching system either allows full page or page-element caching. Full page caching will reduce SQL queries to 3 or 4, element caching depends on the module. If you were using a particular Short-URL system we could make the pages completely static without breaking anything

Contact

  • Name: Simon (simon@zikula.org)

IRC Interview

This information was gained from a chat with Simon (zk-Simon) who represents the Zikula project. This chat was archived and can be read at Zikula IRC Chat Interview.