From Fedora Project Wiki
m (→‎Questionnaire: Fixed header)
(84 intermediate revisions by 21 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{admon/important|The nomination period is CLOSED. The nomination period ended at 23:59:59 UTC on May 15, 2012.}}
{{admon/important|The nomination period is CLOSED|The nomination period ended at 23:59:59 UTC on January 13, 2014.}}
<!--{{admon/important|The nomination period has not yet begun. Please wait for the elections announcement}}-->
<!--{{admon/important|We're OPEN!|The nomination period is in progress! Please add your nomination before 23:59:59 UTC on January 13, 2014! }}-->
<!--{{admon/tip | VOTE FOR YOUR FAVORITE CANDIDATES. | Fedora contributors can elect FESCo at https://admin.fedoraproject.org/voting/about/fesco-december2012.-->
<!--<br />DEADLINE: Dec. 9, 23:59:59 UTC}}-->


For the last election, see [https://fedoraproject.org/w/index.php?title=Development/SteeringCommittee/Nominations&oldid=268106 NominationsNovember2011]
The following [[Elections|elections]] will take place in January 2014:


In the May 2012 election, there are 5 seats open. Open seats are currently held by: Kevin Fenzi, Bill Nottingham, Peter Jones, Stephen Gallagher, and Tomáš Mráz.
* [[Board/Elections/Nominations|Fedora Project Board]] (two seats)
* [[Development/SteeringCommittee/Nominations|FESCo (Engineering)]] (four seats)
* [[FAmSCo_nominations|FAmSCo (Ambassadors)]] (three seats)


== Questionnaire ==
All dates and times noted are UTC time.
The community has submitted the questions that it wants you to answer. The list of questions is here: [[F18_elections_questionnaire#Fedora_Engineering_Steering_Committee_.28FESCo.29|F18_elections_questionnaire#Fedora_Engineering_Steering_Committee_.28FESCo.29]]


'''Please do not answer them on the wiki'''. Please email your answers to [[User:ankursinha|Ankur Sinha "FranciscoD"]] at '''ankursinha AT fedoraproject.org by May 22 2012'''. All the candidates' answers will be collected and put up together before the town halls.
= FESCo Elections January 2014 =


These members were elected in the [https://admin.fedoraproject.org/voting/results/fescof20? last elections]:


== [[User:FASUserName|Person Name]] (IRC nickname) ==
* [[User:Kevin| Kevin Fenzi]] (nirik)
* [[User:Notting| Bill Nottingham]] (notting)
* [[User:Tmraz|Tomáš Mráz]] (t8m)
* [[User:Mattdm|Matthew Miller]] (mattdm)
* [[User:Pjones|Peter Jones]] (pjones)


* '''Mission Statement:'''
* '''Past work summary:'''
* '''Future plans:'''


== [[User:Pjones|Peter Jones]] (pjones) ==
As per the [[FESCo_election_policy|FESCo election policy]], the following finish their terms, and the seats are up for re-election:
* '''Mission Statement:''' I'll continue to work to maintain a high level of technical feasibility and avoid micromanagement in decisions made by FESCo. I'll try to streamline our processes for developers, and to avoid processes that result in unnecessary work, or in duplication of effort.  As I've shown in the past, I'll continue to try to guide our policy decisions to put the power and responsibility in developers hands rather than requiring FESCo's or other committee's intervention and participation at every level.


* [[User:Toshio| Toshio Kuratomi]] (abadger1999)
* [[User:Mitr| Miloslav Trmac]] (mitr)
* [[User:Mmaslano|Marcela Mašláňová]] (mmaslano)
* [[User:Sgallagh|Stephen Gallagher]] (sgallagh)


* '''Past Work Summary:''' I've worked on Linux for Red Hat for more than a decade in various roles including technical support and engineering. I'm one of the anaconda maintainers as well as the maintainer of (thankfully now deprecated) mkinitrd, and am or have been maintainer Fedora's packages for booty, cdparanoia, dumpet, gnu-efi, grub, python-pyblock, syslinux, and others.  I've worked on many levels of our software stack, including implementing installation and boot support for iSCSI, UEFI, dmraid, from the kernel all the way up through userspace. I'm currently a member of FESCo seeking re-election, and have been serving in this capacity since the winter election of 2009.


More information at the FESCo [[Fedora_Engineering_Steering_Committee|wiki page]].


* '''Future Plans:''' I'm currently focused on implementing and impoving UEFI support throughout Fedora, as well as supporting various storage technologies.  As a FESCo member I'll continue to help ensure that developers have what they need to implement their features and bug fixes with as little hindrance as possible, and at the same time avoid unnecessary and wasted effort.
<!--{{admon/important|The nomination period is CLOSED. The nomination period ended at 23:59:59 UTC on May 15, 2012.}}-->


For the last election, see [https://fedoraproject.org/w/index.php?title=Development/SteeringCommittee/Nominations&oldid=339247 NominationsMayJune2013]


* '''What will you be able to accomplish if elected, that you couldn't as an unelected coontributor? Why this post?''': Being on FESCo presents a different kind of involvement than just being a contributor does. It's an opportunity to help set direction and get directly involved with broader decisions, and to ensure that Fedora is headed in the right direction on a technical level.  
{{admon/note|Eligible Voters|Voting eligibility is determined by a community member's Fedora Account System ([https://admin.fedoraproject.org/accounts/ FAS]) memberships.<br/> <br/>To vote for [[Fedora_Engineering_Steering_Committee|FESCo]] you must have cla_done + one other "non-cla" group in FAS.}}


== Candidate template ==
=== Introductions ===


* '''What can be done to get more features and make more progress? Have you participated in any features before?''': I've participated in the "Feature" process as an end user, as a feature owner, as somebody working on features others own, as a FESCo member approving (or dis-approving) features, as an agent provocateur attempting to affect change in the process, and probably some other roles.
* '''Mission Statement:'''
 
* '''Past work summary:'''
I think our biggest obstacles to more and better features are generally with the mechanisms we use to capture information from developers; we're heavy on demanding feedback, and light on doing so sensibly. In fact, the current feature process is still largely centered on "50000-foot" style progress reporting, with little room for nuance or understanding from whoever is receiving that feedback.  It's a show, and it's discouraging to developers.
* '''Future plans:'''
 
 
* '''What do you think about spins? Do we still need them or will they become obsolete once we have a new anaconda with better package selection?''': I think they're a neat idea, but right now there's not a lot of attention that's been paid to how they're implemented.  We definitely need more people
looking at this.
 
 
* '''Do you think the issues FESCo discusses and the decisions FESCo makes are effectively and efficiently communicated throughout the Fedora community? If you believe communication between FESCo and the Fedora community can be enhanced, what first steps or ideas would you propose? ''': FESCo makes an effort to assure that not just our decisions but also our deliberations and rationale are accessable to everyone inside and outside of Fedora, but at the same time, I think there's always room for improvement on things of this nature.


== [[User:Sgallagh|Stephen Gallagher]] (sgallagh) ==
== [[User:Sgallagh|Stephen Gallagher]] (sgallagh) ==


* '''Mission Statement:''' Make Fedora THE platform for rapidly developing the next generation of free, open-source software.
* '''Mission Statement:''' Make Fedora THE platform for rapidly developing the next generation of free, open-source software.
* '''Past work summary:''' Red Hat employee since 2008, Lead developer of the System Security Services Daemon, participant in the FreeIPA project. Fedora Hosted admin maintaining ReviewBoard. FESCo member since June 2011. Currently serving on the Fedora Server Working group.
* '''Future plans:''' Continue to drive Fedora to become the best platform for developing exciting new technologies for the desktop and datacenter. Involve myself heavily with the Fedora Server product development and delivery.




* '''Past work summary:''' Red Hat employee since 2008, Lead developer of the System Security Services Daemon, participant in the FreeIPA project. Fedora Hosted admin maintaining ReviewBoard. FESCo member since June 2011
== [[User:Ausil|Dennis Gilmore]] (dgilmore) ==


* '''Mission Statement:''' Ensure Fedora is sanely deliverable, and continues to be leading edge
* '''Past work summary:''' Former FESCo member, Former Fedora Board Member, Lead for Secondary Arches in Fedora, Fedora Release Engineer lead, Involved in Fedora since its inception. Currently serving on the Base Working Group. Member of Fedora Infrastructure. Red Hat Employee since 2008.
* '''Future plans:''' Enable Fedora to deliver a great core, set of products, tooling and documention to enable people to come up with creative new ways to deploy and use Fedora in the real world.


* '''Future plans:''' Continue to drive Fedora to become the best platform for developing exciting new technologies for the desktop and datacenter.
== Miloslav Trmač (mitr) ==


* '''Mission Statement:''' Ensure Fedora products form a coordinated and well-integrated universe.
* '''Past work summary:''' Currently FESCo and Server WG member, security architect at Red Hat.  Contributor since RHL times, worked on all parts of the technology stack (from kernel through basic infrastructure to desktop and web applications).  Author of the Fedora signing server.
* '''Future plans:'''
** With the introduction of Fedora products, make sure that they make consistent technology choices to avoid splintering the Fedora universe into incompatible subgroups and wasting effort on reimplementations.
** More QA automation - supporting the current tool work, make it more integrated into the packaging process and increasing testing coverage.
** Fedora is often the place where packages affected by changes other packages first interact, and handling this well is critical for achieving good user experience. To that end, I want to improve the handling of changes that affect other packages and ensuring distribution-wide consistency - while making it possible to make successful transitions faster, not slowing change down in bureaucracy.
** I also generally favor policies that allow quick bug->fix turnaround time and allow more enhancements into released versions of Fedora.
** Outside of FESCo my interest is in improving security of Fedora.


* '''What will you be able to accomplish if elected, that you couldn't as an unelected coontributor? Why this post?''': Having a voice in making FESCo policy decisions will allow me to act on my stated goal of making Fedora into a powerful platform for the development of open-source software.
== [[User:mmaslano|Marcela Mašláňová]] (mmaslano) ==


* '''Mission Statement:''' Fedora must be usable as the development platform for all kind of developers.
* '''Past work summary:''' FESCo member and Env and Stacks WG coordinator. I used to work mainly on maintenance of the Perl stack.
* '''Future plans:''' Work on goals defined by Env and Stacks WG. I'd like to see more automatization in packaging and updates. I'd like to help enable software stacks for projects like Cloud or Big Data by SCL.


* '''What can be done to get more features and make more progress? Have you participated in any features before?''': I have participated in the development of multiple features (including two for the forthcoming Fedora 18). I think the best way to encourage more features is for Fedora as a whole to pay close attention to upstream work and call it out in the Features list when those deliverable dates line up with Fedora Feature Freeze. Progress is made when we are proactive about incorporating upstream enhancements and collaborating with those upstreams to take it one step further.
== [[User:Toshio|Toshio Kuratomi]] (abadger1999) ==


* '''Mission Statement:''' Fedora is undergoing a transition from being simply a single Linux Distribution into a project that will create several overlapping distributions and various other platforms and technologies.  I'd like the opportunity to help guide Fedora through the transition so that we can both create these new products and not abandon the good parts of the model that people have come to expect.
* '''Past work summary:''' Infrastructure hacker.  Fedora Packaging Committee member.  Current FESCo member.  Fedora packager from fedora.us to the present.  Involved in the rather ad hoc Python SIG and EPEL packaging.
* '''Future plans:'''  Currently working on how to integrate SCLs into Fedora.  Looking forwards, I think we'll need something similar for docker images and openshift cartridges/gears as well.


* '''What do you think about spins? Do we still need them or will they become obsolete once we have a new anaconda with better package selection?''': I think spins will still have value in the form of live-media creation. There will always be groups who will want to produce a live Games or Disaster Recovery disk, and I think we should continue to provide them with the tools to do so.
== [[User:kyle|Kyle McMartin]] (kylem) ==


* '''Mission Statement:''' Ensure Fedora remains on the cutting edge of open source software, while providing a consistent and coherent experience to users.
* '''Past work summary:''' Red Hat employee since 2007, Linux kernel developer, toolchain tinkerer, general OS bug fixer. Previously a Debian developer and Canonical/Ubuntu developer.
* '''Future plans:''' Bring my experience to bear in guiding Fedora for the next few years as we transition from a mere collection of packages grouped together with little integration into a series of targeted products.


* '''Do you think the issues FESCo discusses and the decisions FESCo makes are effectively and efficiently communicated throughout the Fedora community? If you believe communication between FESCo and the Fedora community can be enhanced, what first steps or ideas would you propose?''': I think FESCo does a pretty good job of explaining its actions and decisions. Our primary communication method is the devel@lists.fedoraproject.org mailing list, which is read by the vast majority of our contibutors (and is searchable publicly for those who don't read it regularly). Our meetings are held in public and are announced in advance for those who want to attend and our meeting agenda is built from our Trac instance for those who want to add something to it.


== [[User:jdulaney|John Dulaney]] (j_dulaney) ==
* '''Mission statement:''' To promote Fedora in my role as an ambassador; to continue to develop test criteria for new features coming into Fedora and evolve the QA process as needed to fit with the evolution of Fedora.  I will also strive to make sure that Fedora remains at the forefront of technology and to be the best Free distribution of Linux.


== Questionnaire ==
<!--[[F18_elections_questionnaire#Fedora_Engineering_Steering_Committee_.28FESCo.29|F18_elections_questionnaire#Fedora_Engineering_Steering_Committee_.28FESCo.29]] -->


* '''Past work summary''' I am a member of the Fedora Quality Assurance team.  I help write test cases for new features, I am a proven tester (testing critical path software updates), I test new releases starting prior to branching, and I help establish release criteria.  I am also a Fedora Ambassador, especially within the Fayetteville region. I spread knowledge of Linux in general and Fedora in particular and inform people that they do have a choice for Freedom.
<!--{{admon/warning|CLOSED|The questions have not been posted. Please wait for the questionnaire wrangler to contact you!}}-->
{{admon/important|Questions are up!|The community has submitted the questions that it wants you to answer}}
{{admon/important|Emails sent!|The election wrangler has sent out emails with the questions. Please contact him/her if you haven't received an email yet!}}
<!--{{admon/warning|Candiates, don't post your answers yet|Once the questionnaire period is over, the Elections Wrangler will collect the answers and post them at the same time. This attempts to make things more even and fair for candidates to be open with their answers and not copy from earlier responses.}}-->
<!--{{admon/warning|CLOSED|The answering period is now closed (after November 18 2359 UTC). Received responses are below:}}-->


* To achieve competitive advantage, have defined a strategy? Differentiation? Focus? Both?
* Do you agree with, and are you committed to, the Fedora [[Foundations]]? If no, what do you believe should be changed?
* Do you believe that it is incompatible with the Freedom foundation to allow ''in any way'' the installation of non-free software from Fedora products without an explicit and informed action on the part of the user/system administrator to allow the installation of such software?


* '''Future plans:''' Strive to improve the testing of Fedora; both personally and collectively throughout the QA team, to continue to educate people on the advantages of Linux and Free Software, and to continue to test Fedora.
= Candidates =


== [[User:user1|User1]] (user_1) ==


* '''What will you be able to accomplish if elected, that you couldn't as an unelected contributor? Why this post?''': As a member of the Engineering Steering Committee, I am able to more directly influence future technologies that make their way into Fedora.  I will also be able to add a different
=== Introduction ===
and new perspective to the Steering Committee, having not served on it before. 


* '''Mission Statement:'''
**


* '''What can be done to get more features and make more progress?''': We should actively search for new technologies that make good candidates for inclusion in Fedora, as long as they meet our guidelines.  On the other hand, why not be the originator of some of these ideas?  Fedora's contributors offer a wealth of knowledge that could be tapped to develop new technologies to meet emerging needs within the computing world.
* '''Past work summary:'''
**


* '''Future plans:'''
**


* '''Have you participated in any features before?''': Probably the most I've been heavily involved with is btrfs.  I have helped write test cases
=== Questionnaire ===
and guide feature owners through the process of getting their features QAed.
* Question1?
 
** Answer1
 
* '''What do you think about spins? Do we still need them or will they become obsolete''': once we have a new anaconda with better package selection?
Spins are exceedingly useful pre-compiled collections of packages.  I do not think that they will become obsolete considering that there isn't room on the standard install DVD.
 
 
* '''Do you think the issues FESCo discusses and the decisions FESCo makes are effectively and efficiently communicated throughout the Fedora community?  If you believe communication between FESCo and the Fedora community can be enhanced, what first steps or ideas would you propose?''': I really do not think the problem is in the system in place.  The system that already exists allows fairly easy and painless communication between the community and FESCo.  Just because the easy communication exists, however, does not mean that it is used effectively by either party.  There is also the consideration that the committee may not decide in a way that the community member wants.
 
== [[User:Kevin|Kevin Fenzi]] (nirik) ==
 
* '''Mission Statement:''' To make sure Fedora continues to lead the way.
* '''Past work summary:''' Have been on FESCo a long time. Red Hat employee for 1 year. Currently head of Fedora Infrastructure. Active in many parts of Fedora to assist others and reduce roadblocks to getting things done and having fun.
* '''Future plans:''' I'd like to make sure we have a smooth on-ramp for bringing ARM folks into the fold. I'll work on adding more Fun back into Fedora and see if we can streamline some of our processes.
 
== [[User:Affix|Keiran Smith]] (Affix) ==
 
* '''Mission Statement:''' Make fedora The distrobution of choice for aspiring developers and systems administrators
* '''Past work summary:''' I am currently a Fedora Packager and Ambassador. I Maintain NginX[EPEL], Amarok[EPEL], ZNC, Nagios and more. Was also a member Zikula Insights Team and FES 
* '''Future plans:''' I would like to bring forward the effort to make fedora available on more platforms such as ARM and MIPSEL. I would like to see a world where fedora becomes the distro of choice, Where we can run fedora on a wide range of devices such as Routers, Phones, Televisions and alot more.
 
== [[User:tmraz|Tomáš Mráz]] (t8m) ==
 
* '''Mission Statement:''' Keeping balance between contributors making changes and stability and usability of Fedora as a distribution.
* '''Past work summary:''' I've been Red Hat employee and Fedora contributor for more than seven years working on packages related to security (PAM, OpenSSL, libgcrypt, GNUTLS, ...) in both Fedora and Red Hat Enterprise Linux. I am one of the upstream maintainers of PAM. I was FESCo member for the past year.
* '''Future plans:''' Fedora must not stagnate and that means substantial changes in the core packages are always happening however we need to keep balance between those disruptive changes and the usability of Fedora as an operating system of choice for software developers and server related work (experimental servers, special servers where the latest software versions are required etc.).
 
== [[User:notting|Bill Nottingham]] (notting) ==
* '''Mission Statement:''' I plan to represent the Fedora community in FESCo with an eye towards maintaining the quality and standards of the Fedora distribution, including features, testing, stability, release engineering, and so on.
 
* '''Past work summary:''' Red Hat employee since 1998, developer on Red Hat Linux since 5.1, Fedora contributor since its inception, FESCo member, Fedora board member, Release engineering team member, and assorted other roles.
 
* '''Future plans:''' Continue to make Fedora the best freely available distribution anywhere. Work with those that show up to make changes, as, realistically, FESCo does not have a significant amount of resources to direct.
 
== [[User:jwboyer|Josh Boyer]] (jwb) ==
* '''Mission Statement:''' I plan on helping the Fedora developer community accomplish the tasks and goals it puts effort into, while maintaing a well-balanced process and governing body.
 
* '''Past work summary:''' Linux user/developer since 2001.  Fedora kernel team member. Fedora contributor long enough that I forgot when I started, former FESCo, Rel-Eng, and Board member.
 
* '''Future plans:''' Work with community members to ensure Fedora is a rapidly evolving yet high quality distribution.

Revision as of 03:53, 28 January 2014

Important.png
The nomination period is CLOSED
The nomination period ended at 23:59:59 UTC on January 13, 2014.

The following elections will take place in January 2014:

All dates and times noted are UTC time.

FESCo Elections January 2014

These members were elected in the last elections:


As per the FESCo election policy, the following finish their terms, and the seats are up for re-election:


More information at the FESCo wiki page.


For the last election, see NominationsMayJune2013

Note.png
Eligible Voters
Voting eligibility is determined by a community member's Fedora Account System (FAS) memberships.

To vote for FESCo you must have cla_done + one other "non-cla" group in FAS.

Candidate template

Introductions

  • Mission Statement:
  • Past work summary:
  • Future plans:

Stephen Gallagher (sgallagh)

  • Mission Statement: Make Fedora THE platform for rapidly developing the next generation of free, open-source software.
  • Past work summary: Red Hat employee since 2008, Lead developer of the System Security Services Daemon, participant in the FreeIPA project. Fedora Hosted admin maintaining ReviewBoard. FESCo member since June 2011. Currently serving on the Fedora Server Working group.
  • Future plans: Continue to drive Fedora to become the best platform for developing exciting new technologies for the desktop and datacenter. Involve myself heavily with the Fedora Server product development and delivery.


Dennis Gilmore (dgilmore)

  • Mission Statement: Ensure Fedora is sanely deliverable, and continues to be leading edge
  • Past work summary: Former FESCo member, Former Fedora Board Member, Lead for Secondary Arches in Fedora, Fedora Release Engineer lead, Involved in Fedora since its inception. Currently serving on the Base Working Group. Member of Fedora Infrastructure. Red Hat Employee since 2008.
  • Future plans: Enable Fedora to deliver a great core, set of products, tooling and documention to enable people to come up with creative new ways to deploy and use Fedora in the real world.

Miloslav Trmač (mitr)

  • Mission Statement: Ensure Fedora products form a coordinated and well-integrated universe.
  • Past work summary: Currently FESCo and Server WG member, security architect at Red Hat. Contributor since RHL times, worked on all parts of the technology stack (from kernel through basic infrastructure to desktop and web applications). Author of the Fedora signing server.
  • Future plans:
    • With the introduction of Fedora products, make sure that they make consistent technology choices to avoid splintering the Fedora universe into incompatible subgroups and wasting effort on reimplementations.
    • More QA automation - supporting the current tool work, make it more integrated into the packaging process and increasing testing coverage.
    • Fedora is often the place where packages affected by changes other packages first interact, and handling this well is critical for achieving good user experience. To that end, I want to improve the handling of changes that affect other packages and ensuring distribution-wide consistency - while making it possible to make successful transitions faster, not slowing change down in bureaucracy.
    • I also generally favor policies that allow quick bug->fix turnaround time and allow more enhancements into released versions of Fedora.
    • Outside of FESCo my interest is in improving security of Fedora.

Marcela Mašláňová (mmaslano)

  • Mission Statement: Fedora must be usable as the development platform for all kind of developers.
  • Past work summary: FESCo member and Env and Stacks WG coordinator. I used to work mainly on maintenance of the Perl stack.
  • Future plans: Work on goals defined by Env and Stacks WG. I'd like to see more automatization in packaging and updates. I'd like to help enable software stacks for projects like Cloud or Big Data by SCL.

Toshio Kuratomi (abadger1999)

  • Mission Statement: Fedora is undergoing a transition from being simply a single Linux Distribution into a project that will create several overlapping distributions and various other platforms and technologies. I'd like the opportunity to help guide Fedora through the transition so that we can both create these new products and not abandon the good parts of the model that people have come to expect.
  • Past work summary: Infrastructure hacker. Fedora Packaging Committee member. Current FESCo member. Fedora packager from fedora.us to the present. Involved in the rather ad hoc Python SIG and EPEL packaging.
  • Future plans: Currently working on how to integrate SCLs into Fedora. Looking forwards, I think we'll need something similar for docker images and openshift cartridges/gears as well.

Kyle McMartin (kylem)

  • Mission Statement: Ensure Fedora remains on the cutting edge of open source software, while providing a consistent and coherent experience to users.
  • Past work summary: Red Hat employee since 2007, Linux kernel developer, toolchain tinkerer, general OS bug fixer. Previously a Debian developer and Canonical/Ubuntu developer.
  • Future plans: Bring my experience to bear in guiding Fedora for the next few years as we transition from a mere collection of packages grouped together with little integration into a series of targeted products.


Questionnaire

Important.png
Questions are up!
The community has submitted the questions that it wants you to answer
Important.png
Emails sent!
The election wrangler has sent out emails with the questions. Please contact him/her if you haven't received an email yet!
  • To achieve competitive advantage, have defined a strategy? Differentiation? Focus? Both?
  • Do you agree with, and are you committed to, the Fedora Foundations? If no, what do you believe should be changed?
  • Do you believe that it is incompatible with the Freedom foundation to allow in any way the installation of non-free software from Fedora products without an explicit and informed action on the part of the user/system administrator to allow the installation of such software?

Candidates

User1 (user_1)

Introduction

  • Mission Statement:
  • Past work summary:
  • Future plans:

Questionnaire

  • Question1?
    • Answer1
Retrieved from "https://fedoraproject.org/w/index.php?title=Development/SteeringCommittee/Nominations&oldid=368458"